I think ultimately with Carson it’s fine. But you just don’t want a ton of those guys.
For me, I think I’d *REALISTICALLY* like
5 top 100 players (yes it’s realistic)
10 other 4-star types (yes, it’s realistic)
5 physically rare 3-star types
2-3 kids like Carson who have great ability, but aren’t there size-wise.
And out of this I would like 8-10 kids every year in-state. Peacock, Utschinsky, Beresford, Evan Weaver, etc.
I think we should always let ties go to in-state guys while maintaining the overall structure I was just talking about.